Yeah Yeah Yeahs: the hall on the third night

Hidden In Pieces Live At The Royal Albert Hall is a live record with one real event in it. Yeah Yeah Yeahs recorded most of it at the hall in June 2025, on the third show of their 25th anniversary theatre tour. The set is twelve songs from across the back catalogue, plus a Björk cover and a pipe organ on 'Skeletons'.

Karen O, Nick Zinner and Brian Chase formed the band in New York in 2000. Their first show was almost an accident: Karen O did not want a drum machine live, so she called Chase the day before a support slot and he never left. Everything since comes out of the same three pieces: voice, guitar, drums. The 2001 debut EP was self-released. Fever to Tell arrived in 2003 with 'Maps', still their best-known song. Show Your Bones followed in 2006, and a third album in 2009 carried 'Gold Lion' and 'Heads Will Roll'. Mosquito got lukewarm reviews in 2013 and still reached number five in the US. Cool It Down, in 2022, was the resurgence, and 'Spitting Off the Edge of the World' came with it.

The record is out on Secretly Canadian, and its centre is the band's first night at the Royal Albert Hall. Karen O has said the stakes were high, that the hall was the third play of the tour, and that the hype going in was overwhelming. The other recordings come from San Diego, Chicago and New York, the small rooms of the same tour. Only the hall set is streaming right now. The expanded edition, with vinyl and CD, lands on 23 October. A 22-minute concert film, directed by Barnaby Clay, is streaming on The Criterion Channel, and it screens in a small number of cinemas this month.

Live records of this kind do one job: they turn a night into an object, and this one is built from songs the band has carried for two decades. The single arrangement that changes is the pipe organ on 'Skeletons'. Everywhere else it is the trio as it has always been, Karen O out front, Zinner's guitar, Chase behind it, in a room large enough to give all of that somewhere to go. Karen O's account of the night is that it clicked when they played the hall, and that every show on the tour was extraordinarily vulnerable.

'Maps' is here, unavoidable, the song that made them and the one most of the room already knew by heart. 'Zero', from the 2009 record, is the other landmark, and if any song on this record was built for a hall this size, it is that one. The Björk cover is the biggest swing: 'Hyperballad' is the only track that cannot lean on twenty years of the band's own audience memory, so it has to be carried on nerve alone. 'Skeletons' gets the organ, and that is the one track here you would play on purpose.

It is for anyone who was in one of those theatres, and for anyone who has never caught the band live, since their reputation was built on shows before it was built on records. Play it loud once, then again for the organ. If you are waiting on the next Cool It Down, this is not that.

What does not work is the release as it stands, and a little of what is inside it. The hall set streams now, and the recordings from San Diego, Chicago and New York are not in it yet, which leaves the album, today, a partial document of a tour whose whole point was the small rooms. One rearranged song out of twelve is a thin margin of surprise. The rest asks you to care about these versions because of the night, not because they beat the studio ones.

Three and a half, then. The band treated the hall as an event, Karen O said the hope was that the tour's vulnerability would translate, and on 'Skeletons' it does. The organ is the moment. What is missing is the rest of the tour, which is already on its way.

Hear it